Sunday, October 19, 2008

A First

I must admit to being a very non-confrontational person. I would much rather walk away from a situation or simply not say anything at all than enter into an argument. In fact I would be far more inclined to apologize (even if I were not to blame) than to assert my own viewpoint or risk offending someone else.

For the first time in what must be at least ten years I have entered into an altercation with a stranger, have politely stood my ground and feel immensely proud as a result. We had spent the morning running countless errands, the children had been wonderful, very patient and well behaved and I told Anisa that we could stop at the pet shop to see the puppies before heading home. She was desperate to see the animals again. After four hours of patience and being told that we were almost done the moment finally arrived and we headed into the pet store. As I looked back and reached out to take Bayan's hand Anisa plopped herself down beside the glass enclosure where four fluffy, little, Labradors were sleeping. Admittedly she did bang on the glass panel once - in enthusiastic greeting to let the sweet puppies know she had - at last - arrived. Before I even had a chance to remind her to be gentle and quiet because the doggies were sleeping and might be frightened by loud noises a complete stranger (a large, tall man in his - I would estimate -mid 60's) rushed up to her yelled angrily "DON'T DO THAT!" With a fury that caught us completely by surprise. Anisa, who had only done it the once glanced back at him from her crouching position on the floor. We were both momentarily speechless. He took the opportunity to scream at her again, this time his face contorting with rage as he he shouted "DON'T DO THAT!" (She had not done it again.) At which point I stepped in. In that solitary moment of speechlessness the following thoughts had occurred in rapid succession: 1). What the...? 2). This guy has got issues. Just grab the kids and walk away. 3). No.

Despite my shock and without knowing exactly what I was going to say I knew one thing for certain and that was that I did not want Anisa to think, even for a moment, that it was acceptable for anyone (male or female, young or old) to speak to her that way. And so, with much civility (if I do say so myself) I said that I was sorry if we had upset him, but that he had absolutely no right to speak to her that way. She didn't mean any harm and that he should be more tactful and kind when speaking to others, especially children. At this point Bayan was cowering behind me and Anisa was sobbing into my leg.

I was treated to a scathing response, dripping with sarcasm and scorn and was unequivocally informed that he had been caned every day of his childhood and that it hadn't done him any harm.

Humph. With raised eyebrows and an incredulous look I politely responded that " Apparently it had." I stopped short of heartily recommending that he seek some serious anger management therapy and turned my attention to Anisa whose tears were soaking a patch in my pants, while he shuffled off in a huff, as grouchy and detestable as before.


Our resulting conversation went something like this:

Anisa still sobbing: " I'm sorry Mummy! I'm so naughty!" More sobbing.

Me: "You are not naughty. It was naughty of that man to speak to you that way. He is quite clearly not a happy person and is having a bad day. But we don't need to let him ruin our day. Look, the puppies are still sleeping."

Bystander to me: " Did you know that man?"

Me: "I've never seen him before in my life."

Anisa: Still sobbing.

Bystander shaking his head: "Unbelievable! I though he might have been a relative or something. He was so rude."

Bystander to Anisa: "You're not naughty. I am so sorry he yelled at you."

Anisa sniffing: "That man was scary. He scared me."

Me: "I know honey. He scared me too. But see, he's gone now."

Anisa: " I don't like that man. He was evil and naughty to me."

Me: " He did do something naughty to you. But I don't know that he's evil. Sometimes people have a bad day and take it out on other people. They shouldn't, but sometimes they do. Maybe he was having a very bad day. Did you hear what I said to him? Maybe he is sorry he yelled at you."

Anisa: "I don't like him."

Me: " I can understand that. We aren't going to like everyone that we meet, but we still need to be kind and polite to them, even when they are rude to us. At least we can be proud of how we acted.

Anisa: " Can we see the rabbits now?"


While it was a extremely unpleasant encounter it has brilliantly illustrated how certain tones and attitudes can have a hurtful affect on others. Now when Anisa gets that 'angry tone' I quietly remind her about how we don't ever want to speak to anyone the way that angry man spoke to us.

3 comments:

Vicki said...

One comment I repeated to the boys more than once is a simplistic version of Abdul-Baha's concept. My version is "happy people treat people well". Simply, the normal state of a human being is happiness and the natural state of a happy human being is to treat others well. This applies even if a person does not realize they are unhappy. (Please accept my apologies for not quoting directly. I just searched in Ocean and cannot find the quote to which I am referring.) This concept has held true throughout many examples, including my own actions. We had a neighbor once who told the boys NOT to spray his house with water (it was hot and they were spraying water around to keep cool). When I relayed the "order" the boys asked why and I told him the neighbor's reasoning: "First they'll spray with water, then next they'll spray with paint" WHAT!? Not sure what kind of upbringing HE had but that was just crazy. And the kids looked at me like I had three heads. I let them know that it did not matter that the reasoning was flawed. It was that man's house and we had to respect his (flawed) wishes.

Tests we are to pass, issues that we might struggle with (confrontation..that nasty concept which I tend to agree with you on) will arise throughout our lives until we learn to pass them. Parenting gives us the perfect opportunity because our intense love and commitment to our children will not allow us to step back from a test.

One of the most difficult conversations I have ever had was this: Carter was 9 or 10 and we had been in San Francisco visiting my sister for many weeks (just the 2 of us). The day we were to fly out I walked into the bathroom and the smell matches was strong. I asked Carter, he denied. (then I checked with the only 2 other people who were adults, just confirm they had not been lighting matches..they had not) No matter what I said to Carter, he remained firm in his denial. We had a couple hours layover in Chicago and I took that opportunity to speak with him about lying. The conversation took about 30 minutes and he expertly tried to change the subject and steer the conversation to something more pleasant. I would not give up and I would not let him take control of the conversation. This has always been difficult for me because I like to think about a situation before responding immediately. But this was my child and I had to make him realize how awful lying is. I persevered with tact and kindness but like a pit bull, never letting go. Finally, he GOT it and the conversation ended well. As I said above, it was one of the most difficult conversations I have ever had and it left me exhausted.

I look forward to your visit along with everyone else....

Grammy said...

Well, I left a long comment yesterday but blogspot gulped it down and didn't spit it back out so you could read it. I'll try again.

I thought you handled this incident very deftly and appropriately. You were assertive without being combative. That was important because there was no way of knowing what was causing the man's behavior...substance abuse, an out of control medical condition, mental illness, a character disorder, etc....or whether confronting him would escalate it.

And you offered a good model to all and sundry, certainly to the children and to the shameful man who bullied little Anisa. But I also hope that the bystander has thought it over and resolved, if he should ever witness something like this again, to step forward promptly in support of the person(s) being victimized and calmly voice his concern or objection to such behavior.

I wonder that there were no staff or security personnel in the vicinity to intervene or report it. I can't imagine (or at least I would rather not imagine) that such conduct is socially (or legally) acceptable there. Your brother hulked up and snarled at the idea of someone like that bullying his niece.

And you should very well be proud of yourself. I am proud of you. You were both courageous and principled in your response and have had the wisdom to turn it into a valuable lesson for Anisa.

I hope the rest of your week is peaceful.

martha said...

Just reading this has been a learning experience here - great response.